Thursday, December 9, 2010
Russian official: WikiLeaks’ Julian Assange should receive Nobel prize
An unnamed Russian official suggested Wednesday that detained WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange should be awarded a Nobel prize.
"Non-governmental and governmental organizations should think of ways to help him," a source in the Kremlin administration told RIA Novosti. "Perhaps he could be awarded a Nobel prize."
The remarks by the Kremlin official come after Assange was arrested Tuesday morning by London Metropolitan police on a warrant out of Sweden, where he is wanted for questioning. He is accused of one count of unlawful coercion, two counts of sexual molestation, and one count of rape.
According to one report, his two female accusers wanted to have Assange tested for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) after both had unprotected sex with him and did not originally intend to press charges.
Assange claims the charges against him are politically motivated.
Since releasing leaked US diplomatic cables, Assange has come under increasing pressure from governments across the globe, including the United States, which is currently investigating whether he can be prosecuted.
Frank La Rue, the United Nations representative for freedom of opinion and expression, said the United States has no grounds to prosecute Assange.
"In reference to what has been published in WikiLeaks I think there is no criminal responsibility for being the medium," said Rue. "This is one of the big debates in internet and up to now the general doctrine is that there is no responsibility just to transfer information."
Numerous US lawmakers and public figures, such as Sen. Mitch McConnell, Newt Gingrich, Sarah Palin, and Rep. Peter King have compared him to a terrorist.
Along with releasing US diplomatic cables, WikiLeaks has published operating procedures for the Guantanamo Bay prison, secret documents from the Church of Scientology, Sarah Palin's email account contents, the "Climategate" emails, Bilderberg Group meeting reports, classified military footage of a helicopter attack in Baghdad, thousands of documents from the Afghan and Iraq war, and more.
Distinguished scholars and activists, such as Noam Chomsky and Peter Singer, signed an open letter to the Prime Minister of Australia on Tuesday, urging the government to condemn calls for Assange to be assassinated.
Singer said there was a "clear parallel" between the WikiLeaks release of the Afghan war documents and the leak of the Pentagon Papers, a collection of top-secret Department of Defense documents on the history of the United States' involvement in Vietnam. Chomsky also compared the organization's efforts to the Pentagon Papers.
In a striking example of the type of information revealed by WikiLeaks, one leaked cable showed that the US military covered up the killing of dozens of civilians during a cruise missile strike in south Yemen in December 2009.
Yemen officials allegedly told their citizens that the local government was behind the bombings, admitting to their US contacts that they'd continue to lie for them, the cables showed.
Although numerous lawmakers have condemned the organization, Rep. Ron Paul has suggested the world needs "more WikiLeaks."
"In a free society we're supposed to know the truth," Rep. Paul said. "In a society where truth becomes treason, then we're in big trouble. And now, people who are revealing the truth are getting into trouble for it."
Assange was refused bail by a British judge, but says he will fight extradition to Sweden.
Wikileaks doubters, please watch this
If Gareth Porter and Ray McGovern do not convince you that Wikileaks and Assange are for real, probably nothing will.
Wikileaks is currently mirrored on 1334 sites - Anon back up
Wikileaks reports that it is currently mirrored on 1334 sites. Anon is currently up at http://twitter.com/anon_operationn (with 2 'n's in at the end).
According to various reports, PayPal is under attack, the site loads, but is very slow. Some people report that PayPal payments on Ebay are not working.
http://operationn.tk/ (http://213.251.145.96/ is up too.
According to various reports, PayPal is under attack, the site loads, but is very slow. Some people report that PayPal payments on Ebay are not working.
http://operationn.tk/ (http://213.251.145.96/ is up too.
The next logical steps
In its attack against Wikileaks and, beyond that, the free Internet, the Empire's two next steps are predictable:
a) Arrests of activists
b) Pressure on search engines
The Bolivian government is now hosting WikiLeaks Cablegate documents
Wikileaks Central reports:
The Bolivian government is now hosting WikiLeaks Cablegate documents on its official servers: http://wikileaks.vicepresidencia.gob.bo/, under the banner of the Vice President's office and the office of the President of the Legislative Assembly. The statement reads:
"The Vice President of the State of Bolivia and the President of the Plurinational Legislative Assembly, seeking to democratize access to information available to the public, are making available the documents of the Department of State of the United States, published by Wikileaks, which refer to Bolivia. All of them are available in their original language (English) and those that contain information relevant to the country, beyond simple references are translated into Castilian or being in the process of being translated, a situation in which we ask for your patience.
The search engine offers search alternatives according to the relevance of the document, its creation date, language of the source institution, etc. We firmly believe that this site will expand access to this vital information and facilitate the work of many citizens."
The Bolivian government is now hosting WikiLeaks Cablegate documents on its official servers: http://wikileaks.vicepresidencia.gob.bo/, under the banner of the Vice President's office and the office of the President of the Legislative Assembly. The statement reads:
"The Vice President of the State of Bolivia and the President of the Plurinational Legislative Assembly, seeking to democratize access to information available to the public, are making available the documents of the Department of State of the United States, published by Wikileaks, which refer to Bolivia. All of them are available in their original language (English) and those that contain information relevant to the country, beyond simple references are translated into Castilian or being in the process of being translated, a situation in which we ask for your patience.
The search engine offers search alternatives according to the relevance of the document, its creation date, language of the source institution, etc. We firmly believe that this site will expand access to this vital information and facilitate the work of many citizens."
Join EFF in Standing up Against Internet Censorship
Call To Action by Shari Steele for the EFF
Over the past few weeks, we here at EFF have watched as whistleblowing website WikiLeaks has fueled an emotionally charged debate about the secrecy of government information and the people's right to know. We have welcomed this debate, and the fact that there have been myriad views is the embodiment of the freedom of expression upon which this country was founded.
However, we've been greatly troubled by a recent shift in focus. The debate about the wisdom of releasing secret government documents has turned into a massive attack on the right of intermediaries to publish truthful information. Suddenly, WikiLeaks has become the Internet's scapegoat, with a Who's Who of American and foreign companies choosing to shun the site.
Let's be clear — in the United States, at least, WikiLeaks has a fundamental right to publish truthful political information. And equally important, Internet users have a fundamental right to read that information and voice their opinions about it. We live in a society that values freedom of expression and shuns censorship. Unfortunately, those values are only as strong as the will to support them — a will that seems to be dwindling now in an alarming way.
On Friday, we wrote about Amazon's disappointing decision to yank hosting services from WikiLeaks after a phone call from a senator's office. Since then, a cascade of companies and organizations has backed away from WikiLeaks. A public figure called for the assassination of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange. PayPal, MasterCard, and Visa axed WikiLeaks’ accounts. EveryDNS.net pulled Wikileaks’ DNS services. Unknown sources continue to cripple WikiLeaks with repeated denial of service attacks. Even the Library of Congress, normally a bastion of public access to information, is blocking WikiLeaks.
There has been a tremendous backlash against WikiLeaks from governments around the world. In the United States, lawmakers have rashly proposed a law that threatens legitimate news reporting well beyond WikiLeaks. We expect to see similar efforts in other countries. Like it or not, WikiLeaks has become the emblem for one of the most important battles for our rights that is likely to come along in our lifetimes. We cannot sit this one out.
Over the past few weeks, we here at EFF have watched as whistleblowing website WikiLeaks has fueled an emotionally charged debate about the secrecy of government information and the people's right to know. We have welcomed this debate, and the fact that there have been myriad views is the embodiment of the freedom of expression upon which this country was founded.
However, we've been greatly troubled by a recent shift in focus. The debate about the wisdom of releasing secret government documents has turned into a massive attack on the right of intermediaries to publish truthful information. Suddenly, WikiLeaks has become the Internet's scapegoat, with a Who's Who of American and foreign companies choosing to shun the site.
Let's be clear — in the United States, at least, WikiLeaks has a fundamental right to publish truthful political information. And equally important, Internet users have a fundamental right to read that information and voice their opinions about it. We live in a society that values freedom of expression and shuns censorship. Unfortunately, those values are only as strong as the will to support them — a will that seems to be dwindling now in an alarming way.
On Friday, we wrote about Amazon's disappointing decision to yank hosting services from WikiLeaks after a phone call from a senator's office. Since then, a cascade of companies and organizations has backed away from WikiLeaks. A public figure called for the assassination of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange. PayPal, MasterCard, and Visa axed WikiLeaks’ accounts. EveryDNS.net pulled Wikileaks’ DNS services. Unknown sources continue to cripple WikiLeaks with repeated denial of service attacks. Even the Library of Congress, normally a bastion of public access to information, is blocking WikiLeaks.
There has been a tremendous backlash against WikiLeaks from governments around the world. In the United States, lawmakers have rashly proposed a law that threatens legitimate news reporting well beyond WikiLeaks. We expect to see similar efforts in other countries. Like it or not, WikiLeaks has become the emblem for one of the most important battles for our rights that is likely to come along in our lifetimes. We cannot sit this one out.
Join EFF in standing up against Internet censorship.
Download our No Censorship button to display on your websites and social networking profiles. Show the world that you are committed to free expression and denounce censorship.
Twitter suspends "Anon" aka "Operation Payback"
http://twitter.com/Anon_Operation has been suspended
http://twitter.com/wikileaks is still up
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
Wikileaks and Operation Payback are on the run but still out there
"Operation Payback" has had its website shut down. It's currently only active through Twitter: http://twitter.com/Anon_Operation. Twitter is also hosting Wikileaks: http://twitter.com/wikileaks. I am confident that Twitter will also cave in shortly.
Facebook is also still up: http://www.facebook.com/wikileaks.
Wikileaks recommends using reddit to spread information: http://en.reddit.com/domain/wikileaks.org.
The people vs. The government
"We feel that Wikileaks has become more than just about leaking of documents, it has become a war ground, the people vs. the government"
Coldblood, Anonymous
PS: The Empire did strike back fast - the website anonops.net is now only displaying a blank, 'suspended', page.
Some more thoughts about Wikileaks
Following up on my previous 'random thoughts' about Wikileaks and Assange, I want to share with you some tentative conclusions to which I have come about the Wikileaks & Assange topic.
First, and most importantly, I have come to the conclusion that these are real leaks, not some kind of disinformation, strategic psyop, or propaganda operation. As of this moment, 1095 documents have been released and, to paraphrase Hegel, this quantitative change has resulted in a real qualitative change. Looking at the scope and nature of some of these documents, I have to conclude that they are absolutely genuine and that they do significantly and negatively affect the US Empire's interests. Some will no doubt fault me for being slow to come to that conclusion, while other will fault me for coming to the wrong conclusion. To the first ones I will just say that rather than immediately jump to conclusion, I rather wait to get the minimal amount of data to form an opinion. To the second ones I will say that in a choice between opinion and facts, the latter should prevail.
Second, it appears that Assange and the rest of the Wikileaks folks have severely underestimated the arrogant, brazen and wholly illegal way in which the Empire would hunt them down. The minor problem is that Assange should have stayed in Iceland where he seems to enjoy some degree of protection, instead he chose to say in the UK in the mistaken hope that he would be granted bail. A far worse miscalculation was to believe that major corporations like Visa, Amazon or PayPal would not immediately obey any instruction coming from Uncle Sam. The only fact mitigating this disaster is that Wikileaks does not need lots of money to continue operating. I am confident that it will be very easy to find money to cover Wikileaks' and Assange's legal costs. Ditto for hosting costs.
Third, the next logical step would be to arrest the people currently doing the release of the documents. Frankly, the idea that these folks are working from some 'hidden location' is absolutely preposterous. If an agency like the NSA (and the rest of the Echelon nations) set its mind to find out where these so-called 'secret locations' are, it will easily do so, even if this is a decentralized effort. In other worse, Wikileakers should now fully be prepared to be arrested at minute and be ready to have their servers seized.
Fourth, the idea of the 'insurance file' is not nearly as brilliant as some think. The problem with this "thermonuclear option", to use the same expression as Assange's lawyer, is the problem inherent to any thermonuclear device: its a very bad negotiations tool. Think about it, if the passphrase is released, then that's it, Assange and Wikileaks have nothing else to negotiate with. And if they do no release it and keep it only as a threat, the credibility of this threat will erode with time. Or think about it this one: one side gradually escalates step by step, while the other side only has one big "boom" option. How credible is that? There is a reason why strategists speak of 'flexible response' or 'full-spectrum dominance": you cannot effectively deter with a mega-weapon.
Fifth, even though I do now believe that the leaks are real, I still believe that there is something much, much bigger at stake: the future of the entire Internet. What this Wikileaks confrontation has triggered is nothing less than a battle for the future of the Internet who is now facing a stark choice: to become Joe Lieberman's latest propaganda tool, or to remain a mostly free medium of expression. It is far too early to call this one, as the resolution of this conflict will involve many countries, technologies, courts, police and intelligence forces, political actors and millions of people. I would only add that savvy observers did see this one coming for years and I personally think that it's a good thing that this confrontation is finally coming out in the open.
Sixth, yes, the US Empire is clearly and irrevocably in decline. But it would be a grievous mistake to assume that being in decline means becoming weaker. On the contrary, we should expect a significant escalation in the Empire's use of force, pressure, arrogant demands and outright violence, even of a 'kinetic' type. Guys, the folks running this empire are not going to gently retire and accept the loss of their current status, power and privileges. No, they will fight with everything they have, baring their fangs much more openly than in the past, and showing their Empire's true face. This is true for the actions of the Empire's actions both inside its 'homeland' (got to love that expression!) and outside. The folks at Wikileaks should expect the worst, no matter how obscene, illegal or stupid. The fact that the Empire is in decline makes it far more dangerous than in the past.
On a personal note, I will be very busy for the next couple of days, so please excuse me if I do not answer emails or comments. Things should return to normal on Monday.
The Saker
Live with the WikiLeakable world or shut down the net. It's your choice
by John Naughton for The Guardian
Western political elites obfuscate, lie and bluster – and when the veil of secrecy is lifted, they try to kill the messenger
'Never waste a good crisis" used to be the catchphrase of the Obama team in the runup to the presidential election. In that spirit, let us see what we can learn from official reactions to the WikiLeaks revelations.
The most obvious lesson is that it represents the first really sustained confrontation between the established order and the culture of the internet. There have been skirmishes before, but this is the real thing.
And as the backlash unfolds – first with deniable attacks on internet service providers hosting WikiLeaks, later with companies like Amazon and eBay and PayPal suddenly "discovering" that their terms and conditions preclude them from offering services to WikiLeaks, and then with the US government attempting to intimidate Columbia students posting updates about WikiLeaks on Facebook – the intolerance of the old order is emerging from the rosy mist in which it has hitherto been obscured. The response has been vicious, co-ordinated and potentially comprehensive, and it contains hard lessons for everyone who cares about democracy and about the future of the net.
There is a delicious irony in the fact that it is now the so-called liberal democracies that are clamouring to shut WikiLeaks down.
Consider, for instance, how the views of the US administration have changed in just a year. On 21 January, secretary of state Hillary Clinton made a landmark speech about internet freedom, in Washington DC, which many people welcomed and most interpreted as a rebuke to China for its alleged cyberattack on Google. "Information has never been so free," declared Clinton. "Even in authoritarian countries, information networks are helping people discover new facts and making governments more accountable."
She went on to relate how, during his visit to China in November 2009, Barack Obama had "defended the right of people to freely access information, and said that the more freely information flows the stronger societies become. He spoke about how access to information helps citizens to hold their governments accountable, generates new ideas, and encourages creativity." Given what we now know, that Clinton speech reads like a satirical masterpiece.
One thing that might explain the official hysteria about the revelations is the way they expose how political elites in western democracies have been deceiving their electorates.
The leaks make it abundantly clear not just that the US-Anglo-European adventure in Afghanistan is doomed but, more important, that the American, British and other Nato governments privately admit that too.
The problem is that they cannot face their electorates – who also happen to be the taxpayers funding this folly – and tell them this. The leaked dispatches from the US ambassador to Afghanistan provide vivid confirmation that the Karzai regime is as corrupt and incompetent as the South Vietnamese regime in Saigon was when the US was propping it up in the 1970s. And they also make it clear that the US is as much a captive of that regime as it was in Vietnam.
The WikiLeaks revelations expose the extent to which the US and its allies see no real prospect of turning Afghanistan into a viable state, let alone a functioning democracy. They show that there is no light at the end of this tunnel. But the political establishments in Washington, London and Brussels cannot bring themselves to admit this.
Afghanistan is, in that sense, a quagmire in the same way that Vietnam was. The only differences are that the war is now being fought by non-conscripted troops and we are not carpet-bombing civilians.
The attack of WikiLeaks also ought to be a wake-up call for anyone who has rosy fantasies about whose side cloud computing providers are on. These are firms like Google, Flickr, Facebook, Myspace and Amazon which host your blog or store your data on their servers somewhere on the internet, or which enable you to rent "virtual" computers – again located somewhere on the net. The terms and conditions under which they provide both "free" and paid-for services will always give them grounds for dropping your content if they deem it in their interests to do so. The moral is that you should not put your faith in cloud computing – one day it will rain on your parade.
Look at the case of Amazon, which dropped WikiLeaks from its Elastic Compute Cloud the moment the going got rough. It seems that Joe Lieberman, a US senator who suffers from a terminal case of hubris, harassed the company over the matter. Later Lieberman declared grandly that he would be "asking Amazon about the extent of its relationship with WikiLeaks and what it and other web service providers will do in the future to ensure that their services are not used to distribute stolen, classified information". This led the New Yorker's Amy Davidson to ask whether "Lieberman feels that he, or any senator, can call in the company running the New Yorker's printing presses when we are preparing a story that includes leaked classified material, and tell it to stop us".
What WikiLeaks is really exposing is the extent to which the western democratic system has been hollowed out. In the last decade its political elites have been shown to be incompetent (Ireland, the US and UK in not regulating banks); corrupt (all governments in relation to the arms trade); or recklessly militaristic (the US and UK in Iraq). And yet nowhere have they been called to account in any effective way. Instead they have obfuscated, lied or blustered their way through. And when, finally, the veil of secrecy is lifted, their reflex reaction is to kill the messenger.
As Simon Jenkins put it recently in the Guardian, "Disclosure is messy and tests moral and legal boundaries. It is often irresponsible and usually embarrassing. But it is all that is left when regulation does nothing, politicians are cowed, lawyers fall silent and audit is polluted. Accountability can only default to disclosure." What we are hearing from the enraged officialdom of our democracies is mostly the petulant screaming of emperors whose clothes have been shredded by the net.
Which brings us back to the larger significance of this controversy. The political elites of western democracies have discovered that the internet can be a thorn not just in the side of authoritarian regimes, but in their sides too. It has been comical watching them and their agencies stomp about the net like maddened, half-blind giants trying to whack a mole. It has been deeply worrying to watch terrified internet companies – with the exception of Twitter, so far – bending to their will.
But politicians now face an agonising dilemma. The old, mole-whacking approach won't work. WikiLeaks does not depend only on web technology. Thousands of copies of those secret cables – and probably of much else besides – are out there, distributed by peer-to-peer technologies like BitTorrent. Our rulers have a choice to make: either they learn to live in a WikiLeakable world, with all that implies in terms of their future behaviour; or they shut down the internet. Over to them.
Western political elites obfuscate, lie and bluster – and when the veil of secrecy is lifted, they try to kill the messenger
'Never waste a good crisis" used to be the catchphrase of the Obama team in the runup to the presidential election. In that spirit, let us see what we can learn from official reactions to the WikiLeaks revelations.
The most obvious lesson is that it represents the first really sustained confrontation between the established order and the culture of the internet. There have been skirmishes before, but this is the real thing.
And as the backlash unfolds – first with deniable attacks on internet service providers hosting WikiLeaks, later with companies like Amazon and eBay and PayPal suddenly "discovering" that their terms and conditions preclude them from offering services to WikiLeaks, and then with the US government attempting to intimidate Columbia students posting updates about WikiLeaks on Facebook – the intolerance of the old order is emerging from the rosy mist in which it has hitherto been obscured. The response has been vicious, co-ordinated and potentially comprehensive, and it contains hard lessons for everyone who cares about democracy and about the future of the net.
There is a delicious irony in the fact that it is now the so-called liberal democracies that are clamouring to shut WikiLeaks down.
Consider, for instance, how the views of the US administration have changed in just a year. On 21 January, secretary of state Hillary Clinton made a landmark speech about internet freedom, in Washington DC, which many people welcomed and most interpreted as a rebuke to China for its alleged cyberattack on Google. "Information has never been so free," declared Clinton. "Even in authoritarian countries, information networks are helping people discover new facts and making governments more accountable."
She went on to relate how, during his visit to China in November 2009, Barack Obama had "defended the right of people to freely access information, and said that the more freely information flows the stronger societies become. He spoke about how access to information helps citizens to hold their governments accountable, generates new ideas, and encourages creativity." Given what we now know, that Clinton speech reads like a satirical masterpiece.
One thing that might explain the official hysteria about the revelations is the way they expose how political elites in western democracies have been deceiving their electorates.
The leaks make it abundantly clear not just that the US-Anglo-European adventure in Afghanistan is doomed but, more important, that the American, British and other Nato governments privately admit that too.
The problem is that they cannot face their electorates – who also happen to be the taxpayers funding this folly – and tell them this. The leaked dispatches from the US ambassador to Afghanistan provide vivid confirmation that the Karzai regime is as corrupt and incompetent as the South Vietnamese regime in Saigon was when the US was propping it up in the 1970s. And they also make it clear that the US is as much a captive of that regime as it was in Vietnam.
The WikiLeaks revelations expose the extent to which the US and its allies see no real prospect of turning Afghanistan into a viable state, let alone a functioning democracy. They show that there is no light at the end of this tunnel. But the political establishments in Washington, London and Brussels cannot bring themselves to admit this.
Afghanistan is, in that sense, a quagmire in the same way that Vietnam was. The only differences are that the war is now being fought by non-conscripted troops and we are not carpet-bombing civilians.
The attack of WikiLeaks also ought to be a wake-up call for anyone who has rosy fantasies about whose side cloud computing providers are on. These are firms like Google, Flickr, Facebook, Myspace and Amazon which host your blog or store your data on their servers somewhere on the internet, or which enable you to rent "virtual" computers – again located somewhere on the net. The terms and conditions under which they provide both "free" and paid-for services will always give them grounds for dropping your content if they deem it in their interests to do so. The moral is that you should not put your faith in cloud computing – one day it will rain on your parade.
Look at the case of Amazon, which dropped WikiLeaks from its Elastic Compute Cloud the moment the going got rough. It seems that Joe Lieberman, a US senator who suffers from a terminal case of hubris, harassed the company over the matter. Later Lieberman declared grandly that he would be "asking Amazon about the extent of its relationship with WikiLeaks and what it and other web service providers will do in the future to ensure that their services are not used to distribute stolen, classified information". This led the New Yorker's Amy Davidson to ask whether "Lieberman feels that he, or any senator, can call in the company running the New Yorker's printing presses when we are preparing a story that includes leaked classified material, and tell it to stop us".
What WikiLeaks is really exposing is the extent to which the western democratic system has been hollowed out. In the last decade its political elites have been shown to be incompetent (Ireland, the US and UK in not regulating banks); corrupt (all governments in relation to the arms trade); or recklessly militaristic (the US and UK in Iraq). And yet nowhere have they been called to account in any effective way. Instead they have obfuscated, lied or blustered their way through. And when, finally, the veil of secrecy is lifted, their reflex reaction is to kill the messenger.
As Simon Jenkins put it recently in the Guardian, "Disclosure is messy and tests moral and legal boundaries. It is often irresponsible and usually embarrassing. But it is all that is left when regulation does nothing, politicians are cowed, lawyers fall silent and audit is polluted. Accountability can only default to disclosure." What we are hearing from the enraged officialdom of our democracies is mostly the petulant screaming of emperors whose clothes have been shredded by the net.
Which brings us back to the larger significance of this controversy. The political elites of western democracies have discovered that the internet can be a thorn not just in the side of authoritarian regimes, but in their sides too. It has been comical watching them and their agencies stomp about the net like maddened, half-blind giants trying to whack a mole. It has been deeply worrying to watch terrified internet companies – with the exception of Twitter, so far – bending to their will.
But politicians now face an agonising dilemma. The old, mole-whacking approach won't work. WikiLeaks does not depend only on web technology. Thousands of copies of those secret cables – and probably of much else besides – are out there, distributed by peer-to-peer technologies like BitTorrent. Our rulers have a choice to make: either they learn to live in a WikiLeakable world, with all that implies in terms of their future behaviour; or they shut down the internet. Over to them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

